Monday, 16 November, 2026
Tim Atkin MW, Peter Pharos
A few journalistic outlets, especially in the financial press, seem to have finally come clean about the seriousness of their reporting, by auto-summarising their pieces in bullet point form for the attention-challenged. In the spirit of modernity then, let me summarise the next 1,000 words for you. Some time ago I examined what the amateur reviewer owes to the provider of goods or services they review publicly.
- This time, I explore what the professional wine reviewer owes to those same providers.
- The answer is: not very much.
- Now, for those few of us that are still around.
Wine criticism discourse is endlessly fascinating to me. Admittedly, this is partly because of its amusingly meta nature (criticism of criticism), but primarily because it is an excellent weathervane of where the wine industry is at any given point. There is something about it that Churchill would find easy to pinpoint: assessing wine is the worst way to write about wine, except for all the others. And while the industry’s view of critics changes from decade to decade, what hasn’t changed is its expectations of them.
Continue reading.